Miami Football coach Manny Diaz deserves more respect among Power 5 coaches
Where to rank coaches in new jobs, first time head coaches and coaches leading a Power Five school for the first time can be even trickier. Is being a head coach more important than experience in a power five program? Diaz has eight years of experience as a full-time assistant at Power Five programs.
Fornelli clearly put more importance on a coach’s experience running a program than having been an assistant with a power five school. Both have their strengths and challenges. The players at Power Five schools are a different breed. Many have their eyes on the NFL. Players at Group of five schools are likely to play in the NFL.
The game resources and pressure at a Power Five schools are also much greater. How the coaches new or mostly new to the Power Five are able to adjust will unquestionable determine their fate. Diaz’s unknown as a head coach specifically contributed to Fornelli’s low ranking for him.
"57 MIAMI (FLA.) Manny Diaz: This is one of those times where I disagree with my fellow voters. Diaz has never been a head coach, so for me, I can’t rank him higher than coaches who have won games. I had him at 64 on my ballot, so if he’s at 57, at least one of my fellow voters thinks very highly of him. 2018 rank: n/a"
Colorado’s Mel Tucker is the only first-time head coach ranked lower than Diaz. Maryland’s Mike Locksley is the only other head coach in a new position that is ranked lower than Diaz. Locksley has a 3-31 record in his previous stints as a head coach at Maryland and New Mexico. He is back in College Park.