Skip to main content

CFP committee suddenly remembers head-to-head matters before December with Notre Dame above Miami

The committee's newfound convenience with the concept of head-to-head is funny.
ByPatrick Previty
Nov 7, 2026; South Bend, Indiana, USA; Miami (FL) Hurricanes tight end Elija Lofton (9) blocks Notre Dame Fighting Irish safety Luke Talich (28) during the second half at Notre Dame Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Michael Caterina-Imagn Images
Nov 7, 2026; South Bend, Indiana, USA; Miami (FL) Hurricanes tight end Elija Lofton (9) blocks Notre Dame Fighting Irish safety Luke Talich (28) during the second half at Notre Dame Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Michael Caterina-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Apparently, the College Football Playoff selection committee has discovered that head-to-head results can matter before conference championship weekend. And naturally, the revelation comes with Notre Dame sitting directly above Miami in the latest rankings.

The Fighting Irish (9-1) checked in at No. 6 in Tuesday's CFP rankings, one spot ahead of the Hurricanes (9-1) at No. 7. The order makes sense considering Notre Dame defeated Miami 31-24 in South Bend on Nov. 7, but for Miami fans who spent much of last November arguing that a head-to-head victory should actually mean something, the committee's newfound convenience with the concept is pretty funny.

Last year's Miami-Notre Dame controversy

The circumstances were reversed in 2025, when Miami defeated Notre Dame 27-24 in the season opener on Aug. 31. Despite both teams eventually finishing 10-2, Notre Dame remained ahead of Miami through the first five CFP rankings. The Hurricanes opened at No. 18 on Nov. 4, eight spots behind the Fighting Irish, and gradually climbed without passing them.

Committee chairman Hunter Yurachek repeatedly explained that the head-to-head result was not enough to separate the programs because they had not been placed in the same comparative group during earlier evaluations. Even in the Dec. 2 rankings, Notre Dame was No. 10, BYU was No. 11 and Miami was No. 12.

Those rankings changed after BYU lost 34-7 to Texas Tech in the Big 12 championship game. Miami jumped to No. 10 in the final rankings, Notre Dame fell to No. 11 and BYU dropped to No. 12. Neither Miami nor Notre Dame had played that weekend.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

When ESPN's Rece Davis pressed Yurachek about the decision, the chairman acknowledged that the teams had appeared in the same evaluation group before the final rankings. His explanation was that the committee previously considered Notre Dame better than BYU and BYU better than Miami, leaving the Hurricanes' direct victory over Notre Dame without decisive weight.

Back to present day

To be clear, Notre Dame deserves credit for beating Miami this season. The Fighting Irish earned their victory on the field, just as the Hurricanes did in 2025.

The situations are also different. Miami's two losses last season complicated its resume, while Notre Dame entered the current rankings having beaten the Hurricanes just 10 days earlier.

Notre Dame was already ahead of Miami in the Nov. 10 rankings, when the Irish were No. 5 and the Hurricanes were No. 7, with Texas separating them. Tuesday's rankings simply removed that obstacle when Texas climbed to No. 5 after beating LSU.

There is also a new CFP provision this season guaranteeing Notre Dame a playoff berth if it finishes in the committee's top 12.

None of this means the committee is wrong to rank Notre Dame ahead of Miami. The head-to-head result is an entirely reasonable reason to favor the Irish, although the committee considers several factors when evaluating teams.

It's just difficult not to appreciate the irony.

Add us as a preferred source on Google