Skip to main content

Heisman Watch: Jeremiah Smith vs. Malachi Toney could've been something special

Malachi Toney's injury robbed college football fans of a great Heisman duel
ByCorey Long
Dec 31, 2025; Arlington, TX, USA; Miami Hurricanes wide receiver Malachi Toney (10) uncovers his face during the 2025 Cotton Bowl and quarterfinal game of the College Football Playoff at AT&T Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images
Dec 31, 2025; Arlington, TX, USA; Miami Hurricanes wide receiver Malachi Toney (10) uncovers his face during the 2025 Cotton Bowl and quarterfinal game of the College Football Playoff at AT&T Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

For as competitive as the Heisman race looked in the final weeks of October, it feels like it's all done but the shouting as we hit the midway point of November.

Despite Darian Mensah's (+450 on FanDuel) best efforts to keep the pressure on Jeremiah Smith (-220), the Miami Hurricanes quarterback will either need back-to-back 500-yard, six-touchdown games or an unfortunate circumstance to keep things interesting with the Ohio State wide receiver.

And all credit goes to Smith, who has continued to perform at a high level despite the injury to his starting quarterback, Julian Sayin. Similar credit should go to Mensah, who is showing his chops as a leader in the absence of Malachi Toney. 

Odds are courtesy of FanDuel. Game odds refresh periodically and are subject to change. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Malachi Toney's injury ruined an exciting Heisman race

If Toney were healthy, could this have been a closer race? Sure. The numbers Toney put up in his final three games were an indication that he was going to finish strong. And there is the personal connection between the two players that attended rival high schools in Broward County. 

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Both Toney and Smith have great respect for each other and admit to enjoying the competitive nature of their friendship. The battle for college football's top individual trophy would also have been a gold mine for all the talking heads out there.

I mean there's a very, very, very slight possibility that Smith returns for another season. He has the eligibility. But there's a much greater chance that Smith will be one of the top five picks in the 2027 NFL Draft. Toney's ascension should continue, and he'll be a first-round pick in the 2028 NFL Draft.  

The top Heisman contenders according to FanDuel

Ohio State WR Jeremiah Smith (-220)
Miami QB Darian Mensah (+450)
Utah QB Devon Dampier (+950)
Notre Dame QB CJ Carr (+1500)
Georgia QB Gunner Stockton (+2500)
Alabama QB Keelon Russell (+4000)
Wake Forest QB Gio Lopez (+6000)

The betting odds would seem to confirm the expected four invitees to New York City for next month's Heisman ceremony. It feels like Smith and Mensah are locks, while Dampier should absolutely be there if the Utes continue winning — it's hard to argue that there is a more important player to his team's success. 

That fourth spot is intriguing. If Notre Dame wins out, which it should, it's likely Carr's spot will hold. But if Russell can post some big numbers against mighty UT-Chattanooga (another "quality win" for the CFP committee to prop up the Tide), Auburn, and win the SEC Championship . . .there would probably be some serious discussion on if he deserves to be in New York as well.

For several months, the Heisman race seemed like it could have gone any number of directions. Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss appeared to be the guy after one month, while Mississippi State's Kamario Taylor was surging and Florida's Jadan Baugh had made a major move up the board.  Now it feels like the winner is all but certain, and the only debate is who will join him in the front row. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google